The British conductor,
Mark Elder, called Tsybuleva "a truly exciting winner" of the Leeds competition.
The Guardians music critic, Andrew Clements, considered that her "success certainly raised a few eyebrows" and criticised her performance of
Brahms's
Piano Concerto no. 2, writing that "for all the fluency of her playing, she often seemed incapable of seeing the overall shape of the work, and her role in projecting it, rather than the detail of each passing moment." Erica Worth, editor of the magazine
Pianist, considered her performance failed to deliver the "warmth, gravitas, a certain humility, a feeling that one has lived, not to mention a velvety rich tone and utter command over the keyboard" that the concerto requires. The
BBC Radio 3 commentator, Lucy Parham, praised her "mature, elegant and communicative reading of this hugely demanding work". Murray Mclachlan, writing in the
International Piano magazine, described her as a "born performer" with "unquestionable qualities as an artist"; he considered that her performance of the Brahms concerto "perhaps lacked gravitas" but added: "there was no doubt that she was thoroughly enjoying every minute. The work was taken by the scruff of the neck and executed with energetic elan, bravura and heart-on-sleeve communication." Mclachlan also praised "her spellbinding, exquisite sounds" in performing
Debussy's
Préludes. Commenting on a 2016 recital, the British pianist,
Peter Donohoe, called Tsybuleva "one of the very finest young musicians of her generation". He commented on her "unerring sense of breathing and space and an instinct for tempo-appropriatenes in relation to her approach to sound and phrase", and praised the "imagination and integrity" of her interpretations of
Schumann's
Etudes Symphoniques and
Prokofiev's
10 pieces Op 12. In a
Telegraph review of a 2018 performance of Schumann's piano concerto with the
Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra,
David Fanning writes that Tsybuleva can "float long, lyrical lines with a cushioned singing tone" and "blend rippling passagework with the orchestra", but characterises her playing as "predictable and short on fantasy", and concludes that she "could benefit from scaling up her musical intentions". ==Recordings==