Another Big Night Down The Drain was well received by critics upon its release.
Popmatters says "Their sophomore offering,
Another Big Night Down the Drain, is a loose concept album full of late-night parties, drunkenness and (kinda-sorta) redemption. Unfortunately, setting the band's stoopid
[sic] actions in a larger context has rendered them far less fun." and "the album's postscript — a drunken stumble called "Good Time Charlie", which heavily borrows its melody from
Bob Seger's "Sunspot Baby" — is the most likeable moment on the record. So I'll end with a question that these pranksters would surely appreciate: Why so serious?", giving them a 5/10.
Consequence praises the album, stating "The best way to experience ''Cheeseburger's
sophomore effort, Another Big Night Down the Drain'', is to turn your speakers up full throttle and just let the Brooklyn sextet take you for a ride. Beware, though, it's pretty powerful stuff. Not in the "heart moving" way, but more like in the "Hey, let's go drive through our neighbors' lawns"-sort of way. In sum, you could do some damage with it, and if nothing else, it'll likely drive your neighbors or parents nuts. No lie, when turned to maximum, this rock could rattle pictures off of your walls. It's just a rare sort of power that's impossible to ignore; sort of like driving by a car crash.", ending off the review with "
Another Big Night Down the Drain is one that will turn plenty of heads in the hard rock world. It may not be a top seller commercially, but those who hear it, will certainly go see this band when they come to town, and that's gonna be one hell of a night. Just bring those tight pants.". ==Track listing==