The game received a score of all four sevens for a total of 28 out of 40 from Japanese gaming magazine
Famitsu. Chris Schilling of
The Daily Telegraph gave the game 8/10. He gave praise to the puzzles and the touching story with its mature themes, stating that they help keep interest even when the game's story meanders. He also praised the game's
watercolour visuals, saying that they make the world a pleasure to be in. Despite mixed reception and lacklustre sales,
Another Code: R has gained a reception as an underrated game over the years. Chris Schilling of
The Telegraph, who gave praise to the game in his review, rated
Another Code: R as one of the top ten underrated games of 2009, in December of the same year.
GameCentral on
Metro UK called the game a "hidden gem of the Wii", praising the graphics, animations, soundtrack, puzzles, and in particular, the story and Ashley's "realistically written" character. Game journalist Chris Scullion put
Another Code: R in his list of the 30 best Wii games, calling it "cracking" and considering Ashley to be a "rare" example of a "well-rounded female lead". A decade after the game's release, in 2019, Charles Herold of
Lifewire called
Another Code: R one of the "top 5 missing Wii games", referring to its lack of an American release. Positive analysis has also been directed at its angle of storytelling. Anthony John Agnello of
The A.V. Club has praised how the game's storytelling "thrived on boredom". He stated that
Another Code: Rs story sandwiches exciting, large moments between hours of tedious conversations, in a way that allows the game to thrive on this, by making players experience the "beauty of real boredom [...] the color of a natural life", in a way that is "unexpectedly intoxicating". He compared the experience of
Another Code: R "to waking up in the morning and realizing how miraculous it is that you are alive". Ashley in her
Another Code: R variation has appeared in the
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate iteration of the Nintendo crossover fighting series
Super Smash Bros. == Notes ==