Editors at
AnyDecentMusic? scored this album a 7.9, aggregating 15 reviews. At
Clash Music, James Mellen gave this album 9 out of 10, calling it "the ideal sophomore record" for building on the band's previous work and states that it "could be the soundtrack to a 90s indie movie, but the tracks stay in their own world; there is no drowning in influence here". This album was shortlisted as one of the best of the week by
The Daily Telegraph, with critic Caitlin Wolper giving it 4 out of 5 stars, stating that "each track contains surprises" and music that "charts the perils of miscommunication amid love, desire, and loss".
Dorks Connor Fenton scored this album 4 out of 5 stars, stating that this album takes "a more exploratory approach, with tracks expanding and developing as they progress" compared to Sorry's debut album
925 and sums up that it is "a perfect addition to their discography and a perfect analysis of modern attitudes and anxieties". Writing for
Gigwise, Miles Cooke gave this release 9 out of 10 stars, noting a combination of "genuine, visceral emotion" in the lyrics along with "metamorphic chaos" that has "a bit more cohesion and maturity" in the music.
The Guardian ran a review of albums that they missed in 2022 and Tshepo Mokoena called this release "reflective, honest, [and] funny". Ims Taylor of
The Line of Best Fit gave this album 9 out of 10, writing that the band sticks to their playbook for songwriting and that this "feels like an album that will weather excellently as Sorry go onwards". Dominic Haley of
Loud and Quiet scored
Anywhere but Here an 8 out of 10 and praised the band's ability to capture the emotions of a breakup, with a "truly impressive" that shows group "as an experimental and visionary indie rock band".
Mojo published a review from Andy Cowan, who gave this album 4 out of 5 stars and called this music a "curious, self-aware blend of warped pop, scared indie and gentle jazz". Rhian Daly of
NME gave this album 4 out of 5 stars, writing that it "maintains their reputation as a band... who frequently take sudden turns that you don't see coming".
Pitchfork published a review from critic Aimee Cliff who scored
Anywhere but Here 7.5 out of 10, summing up that it "uses deeply felt storytelling and intimate vocals to usher us much closer". Chris Conaton of
PopMatters rated this album 8 out of 10, characterizing this as "a batch of songs that feel like they're poking at rock and pop conventions without being a full-on piss-take against rock music". Editors at
Stereogum chose this as Album of the Week, with critic James Rettig writing that "the genius of
Anywhere But Here lies in how those emotions can be jumbled up, become something you're moving past and moving through all at once".
Uncuts Stephen Dalton gave this release 7 out of 10, writing that "sloppy-cool sarcasm and premature cynicism about love run through Sorry's artfully ramshackle post-punk clatter". In
Under the Radar, Michelle Dalarossa rated
Anywhere but Here a 7.5 out of 10 for having "a surprising consistency to the off-kilter soundscapes" in the music, which is "instantly recognizable and wholly unique". ==Track listing==