In May 1887, Sieber and several army officers left the San Carlos post on business, and the Kid was left in charge of the scouts in their absence. The scouts decided to have a party, and brewed up what was called
tiswin, a type of
liquor. During the drinking, several became intoxicated, and an altercation between a scout named Gon-Zizzie (a member of a third Aravaipa band, the "SA band") and the Kid's father, Togo-de-Chuz, resulted in the Kid's father being killed. In turn, friends of the Kid killed Gon-Zizzie. The Kid also killed Gon-Zizzie's brother. On June 1, 1887, Sieber and Lt. John Pierce confronted the scouts involved in the altercations, and ordered them to disarm and comply with arrest until the incidents could be handled properly through investigation. The Kid and the others complied, but a shot was fired from a crowd that had gathered to watch the events. Several other shots were fired from the crowd, including one that hit Sieber in the ankle. During the confusion, the Apache Kid and several others fled. The army reacted swiftly, sending two troops of the
4th Cavalry in pursuit of the escapees. The Kid and his followers evaded the soldiers, while relying on assistance from sympathetic Apaches. The Kid contacted the army and explained that if the soldiers were recalled, he would surrender. They were, and he did, on June 25, 1887. The Kid and four others were
court-martialed, found guilty of
mutiny and
desertion, and sentenced to death by
firing squad. In August, the sentence was commuted to
life in prison. General
Nelson A. Miles intervened and further reduced the sentence to ten years in prison. The five prisoners were sent to
Alcatraz, where they remained until their convictions were overturned in October 1888. They were freed, but in October 1889, Apaches in the area enraged by their release were able to force the issue of new warrants, and again the Kid was on the run. Again the Kid and the others were arrested, and again they were convicted, this time sentenced to seven years in prison.
Kelvin Grade massacre The convicts were initially imprisoned in
Globe, Arizona, but were soon arranged to be transported to
Yuma Territorial Prison. During the prisoner transfer, on the morning of November 2, 1889, nine prisoners, including the Apache Kid, escaped by overpowering two guards, Sheriffs
Glenn Reynolds and
William A. Holmes, and a stagecoach driver,
Eugene Middleton. In what was later called the
Kelvin Grade massacre, Reynolds was shot by
Pas-Lau-Tau and Holmes died of a heart attack; Middleton was shot in the head, but survived, and stated later that he would have been killed outright had the Kid not intervened and prevented his death. Middleton elaborated that he had offered the Apache Kid a cigarette, and this was why the Apache Kid had left him alive. The prisoners escaped into the desert, except for Jesus Avott, who stayed hidden in fear for his own life. A cowboy named Andronico Lorona, who was herding horses nearby, came upon the coach. Andronico Lorona, for the Zellewager Ranch, seeing the stopped stagecoach, drove his twelve horses over for a look, found Avott, and heard his story about the eight Apache convicts headed for Yuma escaping. Lorona took a gentle horse from his remuda and sent Avott on to Florence. Lorona carried the word back to his foreman, who then sent a few cowboys back to the stage to guard Reynolds and Holmes' bodies until help arrived. Militias, bounty hunters, and U.S. Army soldiers cooperated over the following months in a manhunt for the escapees, all of whom were eventually recaptured except for the Apache Kid. ==Reported deaths==