In 1888 he joined his brother at Preston North End. Archie Goodall, playing at inside – forward, made his League debut on 15 September 1888, at
Dudley Road, the then home of Wolverhampton Wanderers. Preston North End defeated the home team 4 – 0 and Archie Goodall scored the third of Preston North End' four goals. Archie was as rumbustious, as his brother John was gentle and he only stayed at Preston North End until 30 September 1888. Archie Goodall appeared in two of the four League matches played by Preston North End in September 1888 and he scored one League goal. As a forward (two appearances) he played in a front-line that scored three–League–goals–or–more twice. On 1 October 1888 Archie Goodall signed for Aston Villa. Archie Goodall' move from Preston North End was the first transfer during a season to be approved by the Football League. Archie Goodall, playing at centre – half, made his Aston Villa debut
on 13 October 1888, at
Wellington Road, the then home of Aston Villa. Aston Villa defeated the visitors,
Blackburn Rovers, 6 – 1 and Archie Goodall scored the second of Aston Villa' six goals. Archie Goodall appeared in 14 of the 18 League matches played by Aston Villa from when Goodall joined the club and he scored seven League goals. Goodall played in defence, midfield and the forward–line for Aston Villa. Playing as a full–back/centre–half (four appearances) he was part of a defence-line that kept the opposition to one–League–goal–in–a–match once. Playing as a wing–half (five appearances) he was part of a midfield that achieved a big (three-League-goals-or-more) win once. As a forward (five appearances) he played in a front-line that scored three–League–goals–or–more on three separate occasions. Goodall' seven League goals for Aston Villa including two–League–goals–in–a–match twice. Goodall scored both Villa goals against Wolverhampton Wanderers in a 2 – 1 win at Wellington Road on 24 November 1888. On 8 December 1888 Goodall scored the second and fourth goals as Villa defeated
Notts County 4 – 2 at
Trent Bridge, the then home of Notts County. In May 1889 Archie Goodall signed for Derby County. ==Derby County==