19th-century developments In 1855,
Augustin Theiner, prefect of the Archive, began to publish multi-volume collections of documents from the archive. Scholarly access was briefly interrupted following the dissolution of the Papal States in 1870, when archive officials restricted access to assert their control against competing claims by the victorious Italian state. Access had remained limited out of concern that
Protestant researchers might use their access to slander or embarrass the Church. Hergenröther's approach led to Pope Leo ordering a reading room constructed for researchers; it opened on 1 January 1881. When the German Protestant historian
Theodor von Sickel, in April 1883, published the results of his research in the archive, which defended the Church against charges of forgery, Pope Leo was further persuaded. In August 1883 he wrote to the three cardinals who shared responsibility for the archives and praised the potential of historical research to clarify the role of the papacy in European culture and Italian politics. He announced that the archives would be open to research that was impartial and critical. In an address to the
Görres Society in February 1884, Pope Leo said: "Go to the sources. That is why I have opened the archives to you. We are not afraid of people publishing documents out of them."
Access in the modern era In 1979, historian
Carlo Ginzburg sent a letter to the newly elected
Pope John Paul II, asking that the
archives of the Holy Office (the
Roman Inquisition) be opened.
Pope Benedict XVI said that letter was instrumental in the Vatican's decision to open those archives. Though the archive has developed policies that restrict access to material by pontificate, with access granted no earlier than 75 years after the close of a pope's reign, popes have granted exceptions. For example, Pope Paul VI made the records of the
Second Vatican Council available not long after it ended. In 2002,
Pope John Paul II allowed scholars access to documents from the historical archives of the
Secretariat of State (
Second Section) pertaining to the Holy See's relations with Germany during the pontificate of
Pope Pius XI (1922–1939) in order "to put an end to unjust and thoughtless speculation" about the Church's relationship with the
Nazi Party. Following the success of the controversial 2008 film
Angels & Demons, adapted from the
Dan Brown novel of the same name, which depicts a visit to the Archives, the Vatican opened the Archives to a select group of journalists in 2010 to dispute the film's treatment. In 2018,
Pope Francis ordered the Vatican Archive to open documents which would assist in a "thorough study" concerning former Cardinal
Theodore McCarrick, who was accused of sexually molesting seminarians and having affairs with young priests.
Archives of Pope Pius XII (2020) Pope Francis announced on 4 March 2019 that materials relating to
Pope Pius XII would be opened on 2 March 2020, stating that Pius' legacy had been "debated and even criticized (one might say with some prejudice or exaggeration)", that "The Church is not afraid of history", and that he anticipated "appropriate criticism". In addition to assessing Pius' response to the
Holocaust, the archives of the papacy of Pope Pius XII should point to a much broader shift in global Christianity from Europe to the global South. Since 2006, members of the archives department have been organising the estimated 16 million pages of documents in order to prepare them for viewing by researchers. ==Holdings==