The original text has been lost, but a reference in a book by
Archimedes, entitled
The Sand Reckoner (
Archimedis Syracusani Arenarius & Dimensio Circuli), describes a work in which Aristarchus advanced the heliocentric model as an alternative
hypothesis to geocentrism: Aristarchus proposed that the fixed stars were extremely distant, and because ancient cosmology placed them all on a single celestial sphere, the modern concept of stellar
parallax did not apply to his model. He placed the stars at a great distance so that their apparent positions relative to each other would remain constant throughout Earth's motion. Aristarchus reconciled this issue by postulating that the stars were other suns that are very far away, In the manuscript of Plutarch's text, Aristarchus says Cleanthes should be charged with impiety. According to Plutarch, while Aristarchus postulated heliocentrism only as a hypothesis,
Seleucus of Seleucia, a
Hellenistic astronomer who lived a century after Aristarchus, maintained it as a definite opinion and gave a demonstration of it, but no full record of the demonstration has been found. In his
Naturalis Historia,
Pliny the Elder later wondered whether errors in the predictions about the heavens could be attributed to a displacement of the Earth from its central position. Pliny and
Seneca referred to the
retrograde motion of some planets as an apparent (unreal) phenomenon, which is an implication of heliocentrism rather than geocentrism. Still, no stellar parallax was observed, and
Plato,
Aristotle, and
Ptolemy preferred the
geocentric model that was believed throughout the
Middle Ages. The heliocentric theory was revived by
Copernicus, after which
Johannes Kepler described planetary motions with greater accuracy with his three laws.
Isaac Newton later gave a theoretical explanation based on laws of gravitational attraction and dynamics. After realizing that the Sun was much larger than the Earth and the other planets, Aristarchus concluded that planets revolved around the Sun. == Distance to the Sun ==