In Roller Hockey International's inaugural 1993 season, led by head coach
Chris McSorley, the Bullfrogs finished with a record of 13-0-1, the best in the league. Building on the growing popularity of inline skating, the team's averaged attendance of nearly 8,800 fans per game, with three of team's seven home games drawing audiences of 10,000 or more at the Anaheim Arena. The team won all four of its playoff games, including a two-game sweep of the
Oakland Skates to win the first ever Murphy Cup, marking the champion of Roller Hockey International. The team beat the
New Jersey Rockin' Rollers by a score of 9-5 in the second game of the RHI 1997 Murphy Cup finals held at the
Continental Airlines Arena in
East Rutherford, New Jersey, to win the series in a two-game sweep. The Bullfrogs left RHI and played the 1998 season in
Major League Roller Hockey (MLRH), finishing with a record of 20-0-1. With MLRH dropping from 14 teams to two in 1999, the Bullfrogs and the
Buffalo Wings returned to play in a revitalized RHI, which planned to resume league play after the year off with 10 teams that season. The Bullfrogs finished the 1999 RHI season with a record of 22-4-2, but lost the league championship to the
St. Louis Vipers by a score of 8-6. The Bullfrogs had won the Roller Hockey International Murphy Cup championships in 1993 and 1997, and won the
Major League Roller Hockey Jason Cup title in 1998 against the
Orlando Surge. After a debt-ridden Roller Hockey International announced that it would not hold a 2000 season, management of the Bullfrogs announced that the team would be in hiatus that season, declining to join other professional roller hockey leagues based on their low level of competitive play. ==Season-by-season record==