His best-selling novel,
If Winter Comes, was in many aspects ahead of its time, dealing with an unhappy marriage, eventual divorce, and an unwed mother who commits suicide. According to
The New York Times,
If Winter Comes was the
best-selling book in the United States for all of 1922. The book was so popular that clergymen gave sermons on the plight of the novel's hero, Mark Sabre. The following year,
Fox Film Corporation made it into a
motion picture of the same name directed by
Harry F. Millarde. In 1922, his book
This Freedom was published to controversy, seen by the
women's rights movement as an anti-feminist novel.
Rebecca West criticised
This Freedom in an October 1922 article for
Good Housekeeping, "Wives, Mothers, and Homes".
G. K. Chesterton, however, suggested that "while the story might be criticized, the criticisms can certainly be criticized." In any case,
This Freedom proved to be highly successful and was ranked by the New York Times as the 7th best-selling book in the United States for 1923 and the 6th best for all of 1924. The publishing historian George Stevens later described
This Freedom as "probably the worst novel Little, Brown ever published". The next year, Hutchinson had another success with
One Increasing Purpose that was the 10th best-selling book of 1925. ==Later life==