Traditionally, the genus
Asarum was considered as a single genus with about 85 species. However, a trend exists among some botanists to segregate the genus into separate genera, based on considerations of chromosome number and floral morphology: •
Asarum sensu stricto (about 17 species), distributed in Asia (mainly China), North America, and Europe •
Heterotropa (about 50 species), distributed in Asia •
siasarum (three or four species), distributed in Asia •
Geotaenium (three or four species), distributed in Asia •
Hexastylis (ten species), distributed in North America Study of the
internal transcribed spacer region (ITS) of nuclear
ribosomal DNA, combined with morphological data, has yielded a better-resolved phylogenetic hypothesis, supporting a recognition of two subgenera,
Asarum and
Heterotropa each containing two sections, rather than the segregated genera above. •
Asarum sensu stricto (
s.s.) : the North American species are
monophyletic and are derived from within the
paraphyletic Asian species group. •
Geotaenium is a sister to
Asarum s.s., showing its close relationship to
Asarum s.s.. •
Asiasarum is a sister to the
Hexastylis +
Heterotropa clade, showing several
synapomorphies with this clade. •
Hexastylis: this genus has been recognized solely on the study by H.L. Blomquist. However, the above-mentioned DNA study provided indications that
Hexastylis is not monophyletic and that some species of
Hexastylis are more closely related to Asiatic species of
Heterotropa than they are to other species of
Hexastylis. The recognition of
Hexastylis has likely persisted due to regional botanists' contrasting the morphology of that section with the regionally co-occurring
Asarum canadense, which is the sole species of Asarum subgenus Asarum in the southeastern United States. However, the morphological character states used to support the recognition of section Hexastylis at the generic level are plesiomorphic. For example, Blomquist provides an enumeration of character states supporting
Hexastylis, all of are plesiomorphic with respect to one or another
Asarum lineage. The presence of persistent, variegated leaves is often invoked by amateur botanists as a characteristic unique to section Hexastylis amongst North American
Asarum species, however
Asarum marmoratum, an
Asarum Subgenus Asarum species found in the western United States also has persistent and variegated leaves (see Calflora page for detailed photographs) •
Heterotropa: this is a complex monophyletic group, well nested within the
Asiasarum +
Hexastylis +
Heterotropa clade. == Species ==