'' January 7, 1967 ASCAP was founded on February 13, 1914, by
Victor Herbert, together with composers
George Botsford, Silvio Hein,
Irving Berlin,
Louis Hirsch,
John Raymond Hubbell,
Gustave Kerker, and
Jean Schwartz; lyricist
Glen MacDonough; publishers George Maxwell (who served as its first president) and Jay Witmark and copyright attorney
Nathan Burkan in New York City, to protect the copyrighted musical compositions of its members, who were mostly writers and
publishers associated with
Tin Pan Alley. ASCAP's earliest members included the era's most active songwriters,
George M. Cohan,
Rudolf Friml,
Otto Harbach,
Jerome Kern,
John Philip Sousa,
Alfred Baldwin Sloane,
James Weldon Johnson,
Robert Hood Bowers and
Harry Tierney. Subsequently, many other prominent songwriters became members. Composers who could not read and write musical notation were ineligible for membership. This requirement, since dropped, excluded many songwriters in such genres as
country. However, an exception was made to admit
Irving Berlin. In 1917, the
United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of ASCAP in
Herbert v. Shanley Co. The lawsuit, brought by Herbert, contended that the owner of Shanley's Restaurant in New York City had infringed on Herbert's copyright of
Sweethearts by playing music from the play in the restaurant without permission or compensation for Herbert. Shanley argued that because there was no entrance fee for the restaurant performing the music, the performance was not making a profit and therefore did not require compensation for Herbert. The unanimous decision on the lawsuit, written by
associate justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., held that any performance of music for profit, including profits tangentially related to the performance, such as the sale of food and drink, required compensation for the original creators of the music. The decision legitimized ASCAP's continued existence and allowed the organization to more proactively seek compensation for its members. In 1919, ASCAP and the Performing Rights Society of Great Britain (since 1997 known as
PRS for Music), signed the first reciprocal agreement for the representation of each other's members' works in their respective territories. Today, ASCAP has global reciprocal agreements and licenses the U.S. performances of hundreds of thousands of international music creators.
Advent of radio The advent of radio in the 1920s brought an important new source of income for ASCAP. The organization initially offered low licensing fees to foster a partnership between the fledgling medium and ASCAP; however, the licensing fees increased 900 percent between 1931 and 1939. ASCAP said the increases were due to radio curtailing the ability of its members to make money through other venues, such as sheet music and record sales, and decreasing how long
hit songs remained hits. In 1940, when ASCAP tried to triple its license fees, radio broadcasters prepared to resist their demands by enforcing a boycott of ASCAP, and inaugurating a competing royalty agency,
Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI). During a ten-month period lasting from January 1 to October 29, 1941, no music licensed by ASCAP (1,250,000 songs) was broadcast on
NBC and
CBS radio stations. Instead, the stations played regional music and styles (like
rhythm and blues or country) that had been rejected by ASCAP. Upon the conclusion of litigation between broadcasters and ASCAP in October 1941, ASCAP settled for a lower fee than they had initially demanded. In 1941, an antitrust lawsuit brought by the
United States Department of Justice resulted in ASCAP and BMI being governed under
consent decrees that required both organizations to offer
blanket licenses of their catalogs to all at rates negotiated between the parties or set by a federal judge.
Membership expands ASCAP's membership diversified further in the 1940s, bringing along jazz and swing greats. In the 1940s, it was common for ASCAP and BMI to send out field representatives to sign new songwriters and music publishing companies, as the firms were not household names; one such ASCAP employee was
Loring Buzzell, who later formed the music publishing company
Hecht-Lancaster & Buzzell Music. Differences in BMI's structure, including providing
advance payments on songs, and an early embrace of
country,
rhythm and blues, and
rock and roll led to an increase in the organization's market share in the 1940s and 1950s. In 1953, ASCAP filed an antitrust lawsuit against BMI, and instigated a congressional investigation of BMI in 1956. ASCAP lobbied Congress for laws that would bar broadcasters from owning BMI stock in 1958, and provided the impetus to launch
payola investigations at the end of the decade. ASCAP and BMI settled an antitrust lawsuit in 1962. During this period, ASCAP also initiated a series of lawsuits to recover the position they lost during the boycott of 1941, without success. The early 1960s
folk music revival, led by ASCAP member
Bob Dylan (later switched to
SESAC) made ASCAP a major player in that genre. Dylan's expansion into rock music later that decade gave ASCAP a foothold in that genre. At the same time, ASCAP member
Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. started having country hits for ASCAP. By 1970, a new generation of ASCAP board members decided to launch a campaign to attract more songwriters and music publishers away from BMI. The campaign led to
Motown Records switching most of its music publishing from BMI to ASCAP in 1971. The organization said that ringtones played in public constituted a performance of a copyrighted work, which required additional payment. Critics worried ASCAP might seek to hold consumers responsible for a ringtone public performance, which ASCAP said it would not do. AT&T, Verizon, and the
Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) disagreed with ASCAP's claims, with the EFF filing an
amicus curiae brief with the
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, contending that ringtones playing in public were no different than consumers listening to a car radio with the windows down and did not constitute a performance. The Court dismissed the suit in October 2009, with judge
Denise Cote noting that the suit did not demonstrate ringtones playing in public spaces constituted copyright infringement. ASCAP licenses over 11,500 local commercial radio stations, more than 2500 non-commercial radio broadcasters and hundreds of thousands of "general" licensees (bars, restaurants, theme parks, etc.). It maintains reciprocal relationships with nearly 40 foreign PROs across six continents, and licenses billions of public performances worldwide each year. ==Criticism==