Asma narrated
ahadith from Muhammad.
Historical controversy The following historians state that Asma was present at Fatima's wedding ceremony in 1 AH: • The author of
Kashf Al-Ghummah • Hadhrami in Rashfat al-Sadi, p. 10 •
Ahmad ibn Hanbal in
al-Manaqib. •
Nur al-Din al-Haythami in ''
Majma al-Zawa'id'' • Nisaee in Khasaes, pg 31 • Muhib Ad-Din Tabari in
Dhakhaer al-Uqbi They depend on the narrations of: Abu Abbas Khawarazmi from
Husayn ibn Ali, Sayid Jalal al-Din Abu al-Hamid Ibn Fakhr al-Musawi, and Dulabi from Imam Baqir and his father. This is a historical problem that has not yet been solved despite the various attempts made by
Majlisi in
Bihar al-Anwar vol. 10. One theory states that Asma Bint Umais had actually immigrated with her husband to Abyssinia, but repeatedly returned to Mecca and Medina. The distance between
Jeddah and Abyssinia is limited to that of the width of the
Red Sea, which is not very difficult for a journey. One narration makes a mention of Ja'far supporting this stance. ==See also==