Using the correct tool for each job is always important. Using the correct type of ASiC container for the job at hand is also important:
ASiC Simple (ASiC-S) With this container, a single file object is associated with a signature or time assertion file. A “mimetype” file that specifies the media type might also be included in this container. When a mimetype file is included, it is required to be the first file in the ASiC container. This container type will allow additional signatures to be added in the future to be used to sign stored file objects. When long-term time-stamp tokens are used, ASiC Archive Manifest files are used to protect long-term time-stamp tokens from tampering.
ASiC Extended (ASiC-E) This type of container can hold one or more signature or time assertion files. ASiC-E with
XAdES deals with signature files, while ASiC-E with CAdES deals with time assertions. The files within these ASiC containers apply to their own file object sets. Each file object might have additional metadata or information that is associated with it that can also be protected by the signature. An ASiC-E container could be designed to prevent this modification or allow its inclusion without causing damage to previous signatures. Both of these ASiC containers are capable of maintaining long-term availability and integrity when storing XAdES or CAdES signatures through the use of time-stamp tokens or evidence record manifest files that are contained within the containers. ASiC containers must comply with the ZIP specification and limitations that are applied to ZIP.
ASiC-S time assertion additional container This container operates under the baseline requirements of the ASiC Simple (ASiC-S) container but it also provides additional time assertion requirements. Additional elements may be within its META-INF folder and requires the use of “SignedData” variable to include certificate and revocation information.
ASiC-E CAdES additional container This container has the same baselines as an ASiC-E container, but with additional restrictions.
ASiC-E time assertion additional container This container complies with ASiC-E baseline requirements along with additional requirements and restrictions. ==Reduced risk of loss of electronic signature==