The first running of the Astarita Stakes took place at Aqueduct on September 21, 1946. It was won by Keynote, a
strawberry roan filly owned by the
Wheatley Stable and ridden by future
Canadian Horse Racing Hall of Fame inductee
Hedley Woodhouse.
USN Rear-Admiral Howard Adams Flanigan won the 1954 running of the Astarita with his good filly Two Stars. On the same
racecard, future
U. S. Racing Hall of Fame jockey
Ted Atkinson reached a milestone in his career with his 3,000th win aboard the
Greentree Stable colt Devastation. In 1955
Cosmah captured the Astarita Stakes and in 1963 her daughter
Tosmah, a future U.S. Racing Hall of Fame inductee, also won it. The 1961 edition was won by
Cicada,
Christopher Chenery's three-time
National Champion and U.S. Racing Hall of Fame inductee. In 1964
Queen Empress won by a nose but was disqualified to second for interference giving the win to runner-up I Deceive. In 2000 Xtra Heat’s win extended her career unbeaten streak to six. She would be voted the 2001
American Champion Three-Year-Old Filly and in 2015 would be inducted into the U.S. Racing Hall of Fame. The final running of the Astarita Stakes took place on October 2, 2005. It was won by Sensation with
Eibar Coa aboard for owner Gary and Betty Biszantz's Cobra Farm and their partner, the Castletop Stable owned by Morton and Bobbi Topfer. ==Records==