Authors of
The Penguin Guide to Jazz,
Richard Cook and
Brian Morton, named it as "one of the finest jazz albums ever made in Europe" and included it among their 1001 best jazz records. Critic
Stuart Nicholson wrote that it "has become a bellwether for European jazz, with critics pointing to how this album marked a shift away from the dominant American approach with the emergence of a specific European aesthetic". Similarly,
Jazzwise magazine stated that it "is one of the most important contributions to the shaping of a European aesthetic in jazz composition", placing it at number 85 in the list
The 100 Jazz Albums That Shook the World.
Manfred Eicher, the founder of
ECM Records, described
Astigmatic as a milestone in the history of jazz. It was voted the best album of all time by readers of the Polish
Jazz Forum magazine. The compositions from
Astigmatic have been repeatedly reinterpreted by Polish jazz musicians, including
Urszula Dudziak,
Michał Urbaniak and
Tomasz Stańko. == Track listing ==