The school was first inspected as Route 39 Academy by
Ofsted in May 2015, which concluded it 'Requires Improvement' although some areas were rated 'Good'. A subsequent inspection in June 2017 however graded it as 'Inadequate' in all areas. The school also attracted criticism for deciding not to enter any of its Year 11 pupils for
GCSE examinations in 2017, deeming the cohort "neither academically ready nor sufficiently mature or resilient" to take them. Following the 2017 report and former principal Jordan Kelly's unexplained departure later that year, the
Athena Learning Trust assisted with the running of the school to raise standards. In April 2018 it was revealed that all of the school's governors had resigned. The school was renamed to Atlantic Academy at the start of the 2018/19 school year, and remains part of the Launceston College Multi Academy Trust. Ofsted branded the school 'Good' for its most recent inspection in February 2023. ==References==