The album was recorded over a period of two years, with ideas for the album beginning in 2017. Recording sessions took place on both coasts of the United States, but they were put on hold when vocalist
Jesse Leach developed scar tissue on a
polyp in his throat and underwent speech and vocal therapy for three months. Following his successful recovery the band then went on a 2018 tour with Iron Maiden, on tour Leach began to experience writer’s block. By the end of tour,
Adam Dutkiewicz took him aside and offered words of inspiration. Leach recalled “I shared my unfinished lyrics, and he said,
‘You don’t even need all of these. Keep it simple.’,” Leach added “I was stressed out. I was insecure. A lot was going on in my head between writer’s block and the surgery. It was amazing to have a friend and producer like Adam mentally slap me upside the face and encourage me.”
Atonement was thus described as a "reflection of perseverance and passion through the trials and suffering of our existence" by the band, While most of
Atonement was written by the time they were touring with Iron Maiden in 2018 some of it going as far back as 2016. It was a conversation the band had London that solidified its direction. Leach recalled “I was like, ‘Let’s just crank out some heavy stuff.’ It’s what we’re good at,” Dutkiewicz added “I wanted to do that. Maybe that’s why I ended up writing all those fast songs,” The album's lyrics touch upon subjects such as social issues and mental health. The song
Signal Fire seen the band collaborate with former vocalist
Howard Jones. Leach touched upon the song stating “I had an image from
Lord of The Rings when they climb to the top of the mountain and light a fire to signal for backup,” “It felt powerful to me. At the same time, Howard’s
Light The Torch was making new music. I thought, ‘
‘Light The Torch’ and
‘Signal Fire’ make sense together.’ It needed to be a call-to-arms, and I wanted to invite him to sing on it. We hit it off for the first time, recently. Afterwards, we were texting back-and-forth. We needed a song with him to show the fans there’s solidarity. It’s a perfect ode to our bond as brothers and a nice nod to Light The Torch.” The album covers artwork was done by artist Richey Beckett, with the art direction and layout being done by the band’s bass player Mike D’Antonio. == Lyrics ==