Bhuvanesh Chandar for
The Hindu wrote "It’s a no-brainer that August 16, 1947 would have looked like next-big-hit on paper. But the abysmal execution and editing fail the material and leave nothing memorable".
Saibal Chatterjee for
NDTV rated 1 star out of 5 stars and wrote "It seems to have been written in haste and staged without much thought. The storyline is a maze, the characters are riddled with contradictions and the general tone of the drama is beyond shrill." Kirubhakar Purushothaman for
The Indian Express wrote "In essence, August 16, 1947 and Vetrimaaran's Viduthalai are pretty much about the same subject, freedom. Even their plots have obvious similarities. Both films are about villages suffering from authoritative forces." Dhaval Roy for
The Times of India rated the film 3 stars out of 5 and wrote "The scenes of atrocities on the people are created realistically and are disturbing in many instances. T Santhanam's art direction and the tribals' look (one person wears massive padlocks on his elongated earlobes) deserve mention." Vinamra Mathur for
Firstpost wrote "Murugadoss' films, even the ones wholly underwhelming, have had some moments of pathos and genuine thrill, even Darbar and Spyder. August 16, 1947, I'm afraid, is devoid of tension and thrill." Janani K of
India Today wrote "Gautham Karthik as Paraman delivered an earnest performance in the film. Pugazh is his sidekick and gets to play a serious role. In the second half, his performance stood out." Nandini Ramnath for
Scroll.in wrote "Director Ponkumar has simply been too swept away by his RRR knockoff to bring his saga of suffering to a close. Emancipation from the unremitting histrionics never quite comes." Mudit Bhatnagar for
Zoom TV praised Gautham Karthik's performance and wrote "Gautham Karthik as Param is extremely believable. He hasn't gone overboard in the emotional scenes, thus making a movie packed with disturbing elements a little less heavy." A critic from
Dinamalar gave 2.75 out of 5 stars and gave a mixed review. == References ==