There is a plaque erected by the Ontario Archaeological and Historic Sites that is situated in front of the present day church. It states "In 1815 some 140
Highland Scots from
Lord Selkirk's
Red River Colony, disheartened by crop failures and the opposition of the
North West Company, moved to
Upper Canada. After traversing the five hundred miles of rocky wilderness between
Fort Garry and
Fort William, they were transported in the Nor 'Westers' canoes, to the outlet of the
Nottawasaga River, which they ascended to Willow Creek, thence over the nine-mile portage to the head of
Kempenfelt Bay. From there, the fugitives crossed
Lake Simcoe, to the southern end of
Cook's Bay, where they disembarked at
Holland Landing in September. They found temporary employment in the Yonge Street settlements but in 1819 many took up land in West Gwillimbury. In 1823
Presbyterian services were held in a building on this site which was replaced by a frame church in 1827. The present structure was completed in 1869." The Auld Kirk Scotch Settlement was the first and largest settlement in all of Simcoe County. The Sermons at the church were held in
Gaelic from the settlers native
Scotland. Many of the original settlers of the area were buried in the cemetery within the church property, which still exists to this day. Presbyterian services ended around 1940 when the church proved to be outdated and too small for services. ==Today==