Trolling On 11 March 2005,
Brian Leiter of the
University of Texas at Austin accused AutoAdmit on his blog of being "a massive forum for bizarre racist, anti-semitic, and viciously sexist postings, mixed in with posts genuinely related to law school". AutoAdmit moderators countered that Leiter mischaracterized the website and that the professor of law and philosophy deliberately searched for racist, xenophobic, homophobic, transphobic, sexist, chauvinistic, bigoted, and anti-Semitic threads in an attempt to misconstrue the site's focus on law school discussion. An AutoAdmit webpage dedicated to providing additional context was created by contributors to AutoAdmit.
Anonymous speech and harassment On 1 March 2007,
ABC News profiled two
Yale Law School students who alleged that harassing and defamatory comments had been posted about them on AutoAdmit. On 7 March 2007,
The Washington Post published a front-page article featuring AutoAdmit that reported similar allegations and raised questions regarding freedom of speech and anonymity. On 19 March 2007, an editorial by
Elizabeth Wurtzel in
The Wall Street Journal criticized the AutoAdmit law message board as a forum of "mean-spirited" gossip. The publicity created debate as well as a new wave of harassment of the Yale Law School students, including an incident that led Anthony Ciolli, a third-year law student at the
University of Pennsylvania and one of AutoAdmit's administrators, to resign. The law firm
Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge revoked an offer of employment to Ciolli; Charles DeWitt, managing partner at the firm's Boston office, explained to Ciolli via private correspondence, "We expect any lawyer affiliated with our firm, when presented with the kind of language exhibited on the message board, to reject it and to disavow any affiliation with it. You, instead, facilitated the expression and publication of such language." Deans from Yale Law School and the
University of Pennsylvania Law School condemned the misogynistic and defamatory postings on AutoAdmit. Others have noted that this behavior is so unethical as to jeopardize one's prospects for bar admission and employment.
Brad Wendel, a
legal ethics professor at
Cornell Law School, wrote, "If I were one of the students who made some of the worst of these comments, I'd be sweating bullets right now."
Lawsuits On 12 June 2007, the two Yale Law School students filed a lawsuit against Anthony Ciolli and a number of AutoAdmit's anonymous posters, claiming their "character, intelligence, appearance, and sexual lives have been thoroughly trashed by the defendants". Filed in the District Court of Connecticut, the case,
Doe v. Ciolli, 307CV00909 CFD, cited violation of privacy,
defamation, infliction of undue
emotional distress, and
copyright infringement against Ciolli and several anonymous posters. The two plaintiffs were represented
pro bono by the litigation boutique
Keker & Van Nest LLP, David N. Rosen, a Yale Law School professor, and
Mark Lemley, a professor at
Stanford Law School who specializes in computer and internet law. It was said at the time that while AutoAdmit's reported lack of IP logging might prevent the plaintiffs from learning the defendants' true identities, the case could prove significant within computer and internet law if it came to trial. The plaintiffs subsequently dropped Ciolli's name from the list of defendants, and successfully obtained
Doe subpoenas of
Internet service providers (ISPs) in hopes of identifying the anonymous defendants. the attorneys had discovered the names of some, but not all, of the offending posters. In March 2008, Anthony Ciolli filed his own suit against Heide Iravani, Brittan Heller, Ross Chanin,
Reputation Defender, the law firm of Keker & Van Nest, as well as lawyer David N. Rosen and law professor
Mark Lemley in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
Blake Neff controversy In July 2020, Blake Neff, the head writer for
Tucker Carlson Tonight, resigned from
Fox News after it emerged he had made anonymous posts on AutoAdmit that featured content that were racist, sexist, and homophobic in nature. ==Notes==