Larry Flick from
Billboard magazine wrote, "First offering from rapper's major-label debut,
Mack Daddy, cheekily
rhapsodizes about the joys of women with prominent backsides. Cute rhymes and slammin' beats add up to a potential smash at several formats."
J.D. Considine from
The Baltimore Sun commented, "In some cases, what's said can be as simple as Sir Mix-a-Lot's assertion 'I like big butts!' in the single 'Baby Got Back'. On the surface, it may seem that all he's doing is expressing an opinion, but there's more to it than Mix-a-Lot's personal preferences. At root, 'Baby Got Back' challenges the dominant standard for physical beauty in our culture, a standard that stresses long legs, slim hips, small buttocks and has no room for women with wide hips or protuberant posteriors. And the fact that 'Baby Got Back' spent five weeks at No. 1 suggests that there are millions who agree with his assessment." James Bernard from
Entertainment Weekly remarked that the song "alternates deftly between a critique of the
Cosmo/
Playboy narrow-minded – and narrow-hipped – standard of female beauty and a bawdy appreciation of, er, generous rear ends." In
Melody Maker review of the album, "Baby Got Back" was named "worst of all" and "a hip hop 'Fatty Bum Bum' and – Warning! Warning! – could be a novelty hit." Mark Coleman from
Rolling Stone said the song "celebrates a section of the anatomy long revered by rappers ("beggin' for a piece of that bubble" is a new twist)." In 2020,
Cleveland.com ranked "Baby Got Back" number 24 in their list of the best
Billboard
Hot 100 No. 1 song of the 1990s. They described it as "the novelty song that never went away", adding, "You could put this on at a wedding today and women will recite the opening word for word before the rap breaks in and everyone (and I mean everyone) joins in. Sir Mix-a-Lot was never shy about playing up the song's "playful" nature, rapping on top of a giant butt in the video." The song has been cited in demonstrating the limitations of the
Bechdel test. It has been described as passing the test because it begins with a
valley girl saying to another "Oh my god, Becky, look at her butt!". ==Chart performance and awards==