Backspacer received mainly positive reviews from music critics, and is the band's best reviewed studio album of the 2000s according to
Metacritic, where it received a score of 79 out of 100 based on reviews from 24 professional critics.
Rolling Stone staff writer
Rob Sheffield gave
Backspacer four out of five stars, saying that it contains "the shortest, tightest,
punkiest tunes they've ever banged out," and that "Eddie Vedder's heart-on-fire vocals are the main attraction, as always." He added, "After toughing out the Bush years, Pearl Jam aren't in the mood for brooding; at long last, surf's up." Dave Simpson of
The Guardian also gave the album four out of five stars. In the review he stated that "the Seattle quartet have rarely sounded this energised." Simpson observed that "this is a record made by mature men with perspective: full of reflection and eclecticism, finding space for both
U2 guitar motifs and
Buzzcocks solos." He added that "the ninth Pearl Jam album may even be the best of the lot." Evan Sawdey of
PopMatters gave the album a rating of 7/10 and wrote that Pearl Jam "have finally re-discovered who they are, and sound stronger than ever because of it". Paul Brannigan of
Q gave the album four out of five stars. He said the album is "largely characterised by joyous new wave-influenced rock'n'roll, and for the first time in their 19-year career, Pearl Jam actually sound—whisper it—fun. No, honestly." Josh Modell of
Spin gave the album four out of five stars. He said, "For the first time in years, Pearl Jam are seizing the moment rather than wallowing in it."
Time reviewer
Josh Tyrangiel said, "The songs here are built on hooks, covered with guitar fuzz, and then trimmed back a bit so the melody abides." Tyrangiel added, "Nothing revolutionary, but
Backspacer provides an adrenaline jolt that shouldn't be underestimated either." Leah Greenblatt of
Entertainment Weekly gave the album a B, saying that
Backspacer is "the sort of sweaty rock & roll that belongs in a bar with cracked-leather booths and $2 beers," and that it "grows same-y, but tracks like the surfing-as-life-metaphor anthem '
Amongst the Waves' do indeed make something old feel, if not new, good again."
The New York Times said that "Pearl Jam... [refuses]—mostly—to equate maturity with slowing down," but added, "Pearl Jam's quandary is that with fewer outside targets or frustrations to rail against, it risks turning sanctimonious... Pearl Jam's music doesn't align well with satisfaction." Joshua Love of
Pitchfork said that the album "seems to suggest in its tossed-off 37 minutes that Pearl Jam have no greater concern and regard for what they do than the rest of the world can muster," and he added that "with the spotlights long since extinguished, Pearl Jam seem content to do things by the book."
Accolades At the
53rd Grammy Awards,
Backspacer was nominated for
Grammy Award for Best Rock Album, losing to
Muse's
The Resistance. Several year-end lists included the album amongst the best releases of 2009. AllMusic listed it on their Favorite Rock Albums of 2009,
Billboard ranked it eighth on their Top 10 Albums of 2009, while
Rolling Stone put
Backspacer at 11th on their list, Popmatters had it as 31st, and
Q on the 35th spot. ==Commercial performance==