"Bad Eggs" received mixed reviews.
Vox ranked it at #136 of all 144 episodes on their "Every Episode Ranked From Worst to Best" list (to mark the 20th anniversary of the show), calling it "straightforward and serviceable-enough horror... But it’s also an interesting prelude to what's to come... Here, as Buffy and Angel make out in graveyards and Xander and Cordelia snark between kisses in utility closets, sex is silly and campy, but very much on the horizon."
The A.V. Club said it offered a take on the same material as the episode "
Ted", with its themes about good parenting. However, they found it lighter in tone and more action-packed. It also advances the theme that sex has consequences, which relates to events later in the season when Buffy and Angel consummate their relationship. Theresa Basile remarks that "Buffy and Xander have a moment where they're the only two people not possessed and realize they have no clue how to proceed, since the people on their team who are actually good at research and book-learning are working for the Bezoar," and that the episode subverts the conventions of the
very special episode: "Any other TV show has their characters Learn Important Lessons about parenting and themselves and responsibility and all that garbage, or else pairs two antagonistic characters together and have them Find A New Appreciation for each other. But no,
Buffy avoids all of those Very Important Lessons and turns the 'pretend the egg is your baby' episode into a parody of
Invasion of the Body Snatchers." Billie Doux asked, "What can you say about a sex education episode that alludes to
Aliens,
Invasion of the Body Snatchers, and
The Wild Bunch? Answer: This should have been a much better episode." Roger Pocock called it "unimportant" and "a little too safe": "In the world of
Buffy, desire is dangerous, and that has been a theme right from the start, but the dots are never quite joined with the egg-sitting thing, which is a sex-education technique that relates to the possible consequence of ending up caring for a child. But let's be realistic, here. Having children isn't the threat Buffy, Angel, Xander and Cordelia face." ==References==