Critical response The film received mixed reviews from critics. Based on 20 reviews collected by
Rotten Tomatoes,
The Banishment has an overall approval rating from critics of 65%, with an average score of 5.1/10. The website's critical consensus states, "Beautifully shot, but ultimately disappointing, lumbering sophomore effort from Russian potential great Andrey Zvyagintsev". On
Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 59 out of 100, based on 8 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews" David Gritten of
The Daily Telegraph called the film "a mythic masterpiece" and that "
The Banishment confirms Zvyagintsev as a director of world stature." Film critic Patrick Z. McGavin said "the movie requires extraordinary patience, and those inclined to surrender to the film's heavy mood and elusive rhythm are bound to experience a significant revelation." The film's narrative has been described as "frustrating" and "suffers from structural problems."
Sight & Sound said "the film's dramatic narrative twist is clumsily rendered. Intended to disorientate, it comes over as contrived." The cinematography by Mikhail Krichman received great praise from most critics. Anton Bitel said "the viewer's patience is rewarded with exquisite painterly images, some unexpectedly rapid developments and a truly bleak vision of human error and its consequences." The film drew frequent comparisons to the works of
Andrei Tarkovsky, as well as visually referencing
Ingmar Bergman,
Robert Bresson, and
Michelangelo Antonioni. Birgit Beumers of KinoKultura criticized this aspect of the film, stating "these quotations are obtrusive and too obvious" while Neil Young's Film Lounge concurred, stating "Zvyagintsev has ended up merely aping the cinematic giants who have come before him."
Empire's David Parkinson said the film "feels more like a ciné dissertation designed to showcase Zvyagintsev's appreciation of the medium than an original piece of cinema."
Awards Konstantin Lavronenko won the
Best Actor award at the
2007 Cannes Film Festival for his performance in the film. ==See also==