The Penguin Guide to Jazz awarded the record one of its rare crown accolades and says that "Oxley's stately reading of Charlie Mariano's 'Stone Garden' is one of the masterworks of contemporary improvised music, a slow chorale rooted in Bailey's chiming guitar chords." The
All About Jazz review by Clifford Allen notes that "though
The Baptised Traveller might seem a conservative step for its participants – a far cry from later projects – it is in reality a swan song for the known possibilities of mainstream jazz, and an exuberant cry for the unknowns of the avant-garde." In his book
Derek Bailey and the Story of Free Improvisation, music writer
Ben Watson claims about the record "If people say that British jazz had produced no masterpieces, it's an illusion created by the fact that CBS had no idea how to market this album." ==Track listing==