Adult males in breeding plumage are primarily greyish above, with two white wing bars, dark streaks on the back, and a creamy neck patch. The face is black, and the crown, throat, and sides are a dark chestnut colour. Breeding females are similar in overall pattern to the males, but are paler and duller. In the nonbreeding season, both sexes gain olive-green feathers on the back, nape, and head. The rufous on the flanks is limited and may even fade away entirely in nonbreeding females. The two white wing bars are present in all plumages. In breeding plumage, the bay-breasted warbler may be confused with the
chestnut-sided warbler (
Setophaga pensylvanica), which has similar chestnut colour on the sides. Chestnut-sided warblers may be easily differentiated by the extent of the chestnut, which does not reach the throat or crown. Chestnut-sided warblers also have a bright yellow crown, dark mask, and white cheek and throat in breeding plumage. In fall, nonbreeding bay-breasted warblers may look very similar to the
blackpoll warbler (
Setophaga striata). However, blackpoll warblers never have a hint of chestnut colour on the flanks, and also have yellowish feet, unlike the black feet of the bay-breasted warbler.
Measurements ==Distribution==