Beautiful Awakening received generally mixed to positive reviews.
Billboard critic Chuck Taylor called the album "a majestic follow-up and the best blue-eyed soul this side of
Motown." He felt that it "percolates with confidence and plentiful momentum" and noted that the album "has a definable signature throughout as if Orrico is performing the set live before your eyes. There are many highlights." Mike Rimmer, writing for
Cross Rhythms, found that the album was "packed with the R&B pop that is so familiar of her style, all topped by her excellent voice [..] As always Orrico is superb vocally [...] Whilst not as immediate and poppy as her last release, this new slightly more mature approach suits her just fine."
AllMusic editor
Stephen Thomas Erlewine gave a positive review. He found that he album finds "Orrico not only delivering more of the R&B soaked pop she perfected on her 2003 self-titled sophomore effort, but also maturing as an artist and a woman. Only 17 when she released her previous album, Orrico owns her womanhood here, focusing on such subjects as falling love and keeping true to yourself [...] These are heartfelt, hummable and sometimes funky tracks that truly showcase Orrico's growing vocal talent and pop charisma." Andree Farias form
Christianity Today found that he album lacked "musical growth" and called it "a mild disappointment considering the potential Orrico showed" before. He remarked that "a couple of these songs are some of Orrico's most inspired, self-reflective performances to date [but] by comparison, though, the rest is all lighthearted stuff. Some of it is even silly, teen-crush fare." ==Chart performance==