Plagiarism In early 2006, Domenech was hired by ''The Washington Post's
online arm to write a blog providing "a daily mix of commentary, analysis and cultural criticism". Media Matters for America criticized the choice, claiming that "[t]here [were], however, no progressive bloggers—and no one left of center with the credentials of a political operative—on washingtonpost.com to provide balance to Domenech." Instapundit founder Glenn Reynolds surmised in an interview The New York Times'' that Domenech's appointment had attracted anger among liberals "because he was a conservative and he was given real estate at
The Washington Post" which in turn spurred bloggers to find "something they could use to get rid of him", referring to the disclosures of Domenech's extensive plagiarism only days after his appointment. that Domenech also appeared to have plagiarized for at least one article he had written for that publication. Subsequently,
Washington Post online editor
Jim Brady announced Domenech's resignation saying "[a]n investigation into these allegations [of plagiarism] was ongoing, and in the interim, Domenech has resigned, effective immediately." After initially denying that he had plagiarized, Domenech apologized, saying that "[t]here [was] no excuse for this. ... I hope that nothing I've done as a teenager or in my professional life will reflect badly on the... principles I believe in."
Payments for Malaysian opinion pieces In 2013, Domenech was implicated in a journalism scandal that resulted in the removal of his work from
The Washington Examiner and
The Huffington Post after it was disclosed that he had received $36,000 from
Joshua Trevino, a conservative pundit and lobbyist, in exchange for writing favorable opinion pieces about the government of
Malaysia without disclosing the financial relationship. The payments only came to light when Trevino registered as a foreign agent of the Malaysian government, and disclosed that Domenech was one of several young conservative writers he had paid to write articles favorable to the Malaysian regime to bolster its image in conservative media. After disclosure of the payments,
The Washington Examiner and
The San Francisco Examiner removed several of Domenech's posts from their respective websites and replaced them with an editors' note saying that "the author of this item presented content for which, unbeknownst to us, and in violation of our standards, had received payment from a third party mentioned therein—a payment which he also failed to disclose."
The Washington Examiner owned
The San Francisco Examiner at the time and thus shared content. In 2020, a
National Labor Relations Board judge ruled that Domenech had
threatened staff illegally and required the company to post notices in its offices and email employees to inform them about their legal rights. Domenech argued unsuccessfully at the time that the tweet was a joke. The
NLRB judge, whose ruling was overturned on appeal, wrote: "In viewing the totality of the circumstances surrounding the tweet, this tweet had no other purpose except to threaten ...
Federalist employees with unspecified reprisal, as the underlying meaning of 'salt mine' so signifies." The NLRB upheld the judge's ruling in November 2020. The NLRB ordered
The Federalist to "direct Domenech to delete the statement from his personal Twitter account, and to take appropriate steps to ensure Domenech complies with the directive."
The Federalist said it would appeal. In May 2022, however, a three judge panel of the
Third Circuit largely absolved Domenech of any wrongdoing, when it unanimously overturned the NLRB, concluding that "a reasonable employee would [not] interpret Domenech's tweet as a veiled threat".
Other controversies A June 20, 2002, a Spinsanity.org entry demonstrated that Domenech made up a quote he attributed to
Tim Russert in a column he wrote defending President
George W. Bush. Domenech responded by saying he would produce evidence that the quote was not "fictitious", but was unable to do so. In a 2010 post written for CBS, Domenech incorrectly described Supreme Court Justice nominee
Elena Kagan as the high court's "first openly
gay justice". Dan Farber, the-then editor-in-chief of CBSNews.com, subsequently said in a statement that "after looking at the facts we determined that it was nothing but pure and irresponsible speculation on the blogger's part." Domenech, however, doubled down, writing in an addendum to his column, "I have to correct my text here to say that Kagan is apparently still
closeted—odd, because her female partner is rather well known in Harvard circles." Domenech once again provided no credible evidence, to verify his claim. In fact, numerous reports confirmed that Kagan was not gay, forcing Domenech finally to issue a public apology to Kagan "if she [was] offended at all by my repetition of a Harvard rumor in a speculative blog post." In July 2018, on the day that the Special Counsel
Robert Mueller's investigation into
Russian interference in the 2016 election indicted 12 Russian agents, Domenech disseminated information from a hoax version of the indictment documents. Domenech falsely reported that "much of it [the indictment] is taken up by the numbers of times that people were posting memes on the internet", citing the fake indictment, which claimed that the 12 Russians charged had only engaged in insignificant "
shitposting" and the use of memes. In May 2019, Domenech's wife
Meghan McCain appeared on
Late Night with Seth Meyers, where she and host
Seth Meyers discussed McCain's assertion that Rep.
Ilhan Omar was anti-Semitic. Shortly thereafter, Domenech posted a number of crude tweets targeting Meyers, calling Meyers an "untalented piece of shit" and "monumental asshole" who "only has his job because he regularly gargled
Lorne Michaels' balls".
The Daily Beast described Domenech's behavior as him having gone "on an unhinged rant against the late-night host ... that was at times
homophobic". Domenech later deleted his tweets and apologized for "rage tweeting". ==Personal life==