Graham was first approached by the
New York Jets to try out as a punter in 1997; however, he decided to stay in the AFL. In 2004, he surprised many in Australia when he quit Australian rules football and left for the United States to pursue a career as a
punter in the
National Football League, where he would ultimately be paid many times more than he would have earned in Australia and extended his playing career by many years.
New York Jets Graham was signed to a short-term contract by the New York Jets in January 2005. On 22 May 2006, the Jets signed Graham to a six-year contract worth US$5.17 million. Graham also used the Australian
drop punt—a style of kicking prevalent in Australian rules football first introduced in 1997 to the NFL by fellow Australian Darren Bennett—which improves kicking efficiency and is said to be an innovation to the game of American football. The Jets waived Graham on 16 September 2008, but he did not miss a game: they quickly re-signed him on 22 September due to a minor injury to his replacement
Reggie Hodges. Graham was released again on 29 September after Hodges recovered.
New Orleans Saints On 20 October 2008, Graham signed with the
New Orleans Saints to play a game in London. The team had released incumbent punter
Steve Weatherford earlier in the week due to travel arrangement issues. He played just the one game, punting three times with an average of 42 yards, before being released on 29 October. He was replaced by
Glenn Pakulak.
Arizona Cardinals Graham was signed by the
Arizona Cardinals on 1 December 2008 after the team released
punter Dirk Johnson; this was the second time that Johnson had been replaced by an Australian punter. In the NFC Championship game that year, Graham's Cardinals played the
Philadelphia Eagles, whose punter,
Sav Rocca, also was an ex-AFL player from
Collingwood and
North Melbourne. This guaranteed that one of the two would be the first Australian to play in a
Super Bowl. The Cardinals' victory presented that honour to Graham. The Cardinals released Graham on 2 September 2011, before the start of the season. But they re-signed him on 5 October; he was released again on 11 October, after one game covering for the injured
Dave Zastudil.
Detroit Lions On 15 November 2011, Graham signed with the
Detroit Lions, replacing
Robert Malone. Malone had played only one game after replacing the injured
Ryan Donahue. During the 2012 preseason, Graham beat out Donahue for the starting job. On 25 September 2012, Graham was placed on the season-ending injured reserve list.
Nick Harris was signed to replace Graham for the remainder of the season. He was released with an injury settlement later that season.
International career In 2011 with the
NFL lockout looming, Graham announced his intention to play for the
Australian National team in the
2011 IFAF World Cup, the official international American Football championship tournament. Later, he officially was added to the roster as the country's starting punter. ==Post-playing career==