In 1907, the
Leiden professor
Petrus Blok published the last part of his
History of the Dutch People, dedicated to the arts. However, he totally ignored music, claiming Dutch music did not possess any 'national character'. The composer
Johan Wagenaar published a rebuttal, in which he claimed that 'true' Dutch music could be characterised by a 'simple, spirited or firm melody, by a sense of the cosy and quietly sensitive, a sharp rhythm and, finally, a sense of humour'. Wagenaar named two works as an example:
Peter van Anrooy's
Piet Hein Rhapsody, an orchestral pot-boiler based on a popular song about the seventeenth century Dutch naval hero
Piet Hein and Bernard Zweers'
Third Symphony, subtitled 'To My Fatherland'. Indeed, Zweers could be said to be the most overtly nationalistic of all Dutch composers. Not in the sense that, like so many other European composers, he based his music exclusively on folk music, but more in his exploitation of national themes. However, there is a strange dichotomy in Zweers' ideas about music. On the one hand, he strived to develop a specifically
Dutch brand of music, free from foreign influence. For instance, his vocal music only employs Dutch-language texts, and when it has a programme, that is frequently inspired by Dutch themes:
Rembrandt,
Vondel's Gijsbrecht van Aemstel, Dutch landscapes, and so forth. His aim was the greater good of Dutch art, because "Never will art get a foothold with a people, when it uses a foreign language in song, or when it takes in art by means of foreign tongues". On the other hand, the
German influences in his music are undeniable. His
Second Symphony is thoroughly Wagnerian; his Third gave him the epithet 'the Dutch
Bruckner'. One cannot imagine Zweers much appreciating that honour (and it really is undeserved as well, since the only Brucknerian thing about the work is its length). That
Third Symphony (1887–1889) was to become by far Zweers' most famous work. Its large scale prohibited it from being performed very often and made publication expensive (the publisher A.A.
Noske experienced a great loss as sales were poor), but the work was, and is, regarded as a milestone in the development of Dutch music, combining folk tunes with a lyrical description of Dutch landscapes. It was therefore unavoidable that
Wagenaar should use it as an example of 'typical' Dutch music. == References ==