Boxcar Bertha received mixed reviews from critics. It holds an approval rating of 54% on
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes based on 26 reviews, with an average rating of 5.2/10. The website's critical consensus says, "Too derivative of other
Roger Corman crime pictures to stand out,
Boxcar Bertha feels more like a training exercise for a fledgling Martin Scorsese than a fully formed picture in its own right." Scorsese screened a rough cut of the film for
John Cassavetes. Cassavetes took him into his office and told him, "Marty, you've just spent a whole year of your life making a piece of shit. It's a good picture, but you're better than the people who make this kind of movie. Don't get hooked into the
exploitation market, just try and do something different." This advice inspired Scorsese in working on his next film,
Mean Streets.
Roger Ebert of the
Chicago Sun-Times gave the film three stars out of four and called it "a weirdly interesting movie ... Director Martin Scorsese has gone for mood and atmosphere more than for action, and his violence is always blunt and unpleasant — never liberating and exhilarating, as the New Violence is supposed to be. We get the feeling we're inhabiting the dark night of a soul."
The New York Times Howard Thompson found the film to be an "interesting surprise", praising Carradine's "excellent" performance and the "beautiful" direction by Scorsese, "who really comes into his own here."
Kevin Thomas of the
Los Angeles Times wrote, "What is most impressive about
Boxcar Bertha ... is how 28-year old director Martin Scorsese, in his first Hollywood venture, has managed to shape such familiar material into a viable film." Arthur D. Murphy of
Variety gave the film a negative review, writing, "Whatever its intentions,
Boxcar Bertha is not much more than an excuse to slaughter a lot of people ... The final cut has stripped away whatever mood and motivation may have been in the script, leaving little more than fights, shotgun blasts, beatings and aimless movement."
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune gave the film one star out of four and called it a "trashy movie" with violence that "does not shock. It merely depresses."
Tom Milne of
The Monthly Film Bulletin declared: "Abrasively scripted, stunningly shot, and beautifully acted by David Carradine, Barbara Hershey and Barry Primus in particular,
Boxcar Bertha is much more than the exploitation picture it has been written off as (by
Variety, for instance) and makes a worthy companion piece to both
Bloody Mama and
Bonnie and Clyde." ==See also==