The play opened
Off-Broadway at the
Atlantic Theater Company's
Linda Gross Theater, with previews that began on July 10, 2014, and a premiere on July 31. Its initial run was extended from August 16 to 23. A
Second Stage Theatre production ran from February 11, 2015, until March 22, 2015, at the company's Tony Kiser Theatre, with previews beginning on January 16. The play was directed by
Austin Pendleton, with a cast that featured
Stephen McKinley Henderson as Walter "Pops" Washington, Victor Almanzar (Oswaldo), Rosal Colon (Lulu),
Liza Colón-Zayas (Church Lady), and
Ron Cephas Jones (Junior) (Ray Anthony Thomas played Junior in the 2014 production).
Michael Rispoli played the chief antagonist (Lt. Caro) and Elizabeth Canavan played the ambivalent role of Pops' old partner (Detective O'Connor) The play was produced at the
American Conservatory Theater, Geary Theater in
San Francisco in September 2015. Directed by Irene Lewis, the cast featured
Carl Lumbly as Pops, Catherine Castellanos as the Church Lady, Samuel Ray Gates as Junior, Elia Monte-Brown as Lulu, and Lakin Valdez as Oswaldo. Studio Theatre in
Washington, DC, staged the play from January 13, 2016, to February 28, 2016.
Artists Repertory Theatre, located in
Portland, Oregon, staged
Between Riverside and Crazy from March 4 to April 1, 2018. Speakeasy Stage Company, located in
Boston, Massachusetts, staged
Between Riverside and Crazy from September 7 to October 6, 2018, starring
Tyrees Allen (Pops), Alejandro Simoes (Oswaldo), Stewart Evan Smith (Junior), Octavia Chavez-Richmond (Lulu), Celeste Oliva (Church Lady), Maureen Keiller (Det. O'Connor), and Lewis D. Wheeler (Lt. Caro). American Stage Company, located in
St. Petersburg, Florida, staged
Between Riverside and Crazy from October 3 to November 4, 2018. The play made its
Broadway debut at the
Hayes Theater in previews on November 30, 2022, and officially opened on December 19. The production was directed by Austin Pendleton and featured much of the original off-Broadway cast. The production closed on February 19, 2023. ==Critical response==