Ivory pomegranate The Biblical Archaeology Society and its founder Hershel Shanks were first involved in a dispute of authenticity after the discovery of an
ivory pomegranate with the inscription "Holy to the priests, belonging to the Temple of Yahweh", said to be the only remaining artefact from the First Temple of Solomon. After being purchased by academic epigraphist
André Lemaire in a Jerusalem antiquities dealership for US$3,000, Shanks provided an accessible account of the pomegranate's discovery in the
Biblical Archaeology Review. In May 2002, Tel Aviv engineer
Oded Golan purchased a limestone ossuary (burial box) from the 1st century, adorned with the Aramaic inscription "James, Son of Joseph, Brother of Jesus". The Authority suggested that the discovery was "the fraud of the century". The Ossuary's original dealer was subsequently charged, and later acquitted, for operating an international forgery ring and for faking the inscription in question. Regarding the Biblical Archaeology Society's ongoing insistence of the Ossuary's authenticity, some scholars have suggested at the financial motives and public exposure gained through its legitimacy.
Dead Sea Scrolls Whilst the Biblical Archaeology Society was decisive in the releasing of the
Dead Sea Scrolls, in August 2000, Qimron objected to both the publication of a working composite scroll text 'MMT' of which for years he had been actively engaged in translating, in addition to the publications forward whereby Shanks alluded to the preventative and controlling behaviours of interested scholars. Shanks and the Biblical Archaeology Society refuted this claim, suggesting that the work was published in an attempt to illuminate "how hard the establishment was working to keep things to themselves." The Judge concluded that Qimron did in fact have copyright to his work due to the necessary assembly of 'MMT' depending on linguistic research, consisting original creation. Subsequently, Shanks and the Biblical Archeology Society were sued over copyright violation and liable for $100,000 in damages due to loss of publishing royalties, loss of income, mental anguish and injury to Qimron's reputation. In his 2010 autobiography
Freeing the Dead Sea Scrolls: And Other Adventures of an Archaeology Outsider, Shanks addresses events and admits that the Biblical Archaeology Society was often charged with accusations of "controversy". The book also discusses yet another controversy the society was involved in, whereby it was associated with the discovery of the Yehoash Plaque, a 15-line Hebrew inscription that was also deemed a forgery. However, Shanks goes on to accuse the
Israel Antiquities Authority of "engaging in politicised archaeology" on matters of authenticity. ==References==