The second-generation instrument was BICEP2. the accepted and reviewed version of the discovery paper contains an appendix discussing the possible production of the signal by
cosmic dust. this is considered the most likely explanation for the detected signal by many scientists. For example, on June 5, 2014 at a conference of the
American Astronomical Society, astronomer
David Spergel argued that the B-mode polarization detected by BICEP2 could instead be the result of light emitted from dust between the stars in our
Milky Way galaxy. A
preprint released by the
Planck team in September 2014, eventually accepted in 2016, provided the most accurate measurement yet of dust, concluding that the signal from dust is the same strength as that reported from BICEP2. On January 30, 2015, a joint analysis of BICEP2 and
Planck data was published and the
European Space Agency announced that the signal can be entirely attributed to
dust in the Milky Way. BICEP2 has combined their data with the Keck Array and Planck in a joint analysis. A March 2015 publication in
Physical Review Letters set a limit on the tensor-to-scalar ratio of . The BICEP2 affair forms the subject of
a book by Brian Keating. ==Keck Array==