Commentators discussed several omissions of potential titles:
J. R. R. Tolkien's
The Lord of the Rings (ranked number 1 in the 2003
The Big Read);
J. K. Rowling's
Harry Potter books;
Philip Pullman's
His Dark Materials trilogy, and the work of
Dick Francis, reportedly one of the Queen's favourite authors. The inclusion of Northern Irish writer
Seamus Heaney was explained by the fact that when he wrote
Death of a Naturalist he was living in the UK and published by an English publisher; Heaney identified as an
Irish nationalist and had previously objected to his inclusion in
The Penguin Book of Contemporary British Poetry. In
The Telegraph,
Allison Pearson called it a You'll take your medicine and like it' kind of list compiled by people who were scared stiff of not being diverse enough." Similarly, in
The Article, David Herman complained: "If you like
Hornblower or
James Bond, witches and hobbits, great children's literature, popular poetry or drama, The Big Jubilee Read doesn't care. What it does care about is
post-colonial, ideally non-white, literature." ==References==