My Bloody Valentine in 1989 Butcher was recruited as a vocalist for
My Bloody Valentine in April 1987. She replaced original vocalist
David Conway and shared vocal duties briefly with Joe Byfield. Butcher, whose prior musical experience was playing classical guitar as a child and singing and playing tambourine "with some girlfriends for fun", learned that the group needed a backing vocalist from her boyfriend, who had met drummer
Colm Ó Cíosóig on a ferry from the Netherlands. At her audition for the band, she sang "
The Bargain Store", a song from
Dolly Parton's 1975
album of the same name. Butcher was featured as co-vocalist and co-guitarist on My Bloody Valentine's non-album single, "
Strawberry Wine", and the band's second
mini album,
Ecstasy, both of which were released in 1987 on Lazy Records. She performed vocals and guitar on all further My Bloody Valentine releases, until the band's second studio album
Loveless (1991), on which her guitar duties were performed by co-vocalist and guitarist
Kevin Shields. She contributed a third of the lyrics to ''
Isn't Anything (1988) and Loveless
, as well as other releases including You Made Me Realise (1988), Glider (1990) and Tremolo'' (1991). My Bloody Valentine attempted to record a third studio album after signing with
Island Records in October 1992 for a reported £250,000 contract. The band's advance went towards the construction of a home studio in
Streatham, South London, which was completed in April 1993. Several technical problems with the studio sent the band into "semi-meltdown", according to Shields. The band then went on an extended hiatus. My Bloody Valentine reunited in 2007, and released their third album,
m b v, in 2013. My Bloody Valentine began a worldwide tour in November 2025.
Other collaborations Butcher performed lead vocals on two tracks—"Ballad Night" and "Casino Kisschase"—on the
hip hop band
Collapsed Lung's album
Cooler (1996), and performed backing vocals on the
Dinosaur Jr song "I Don't Think" from
Hand It Over (1997). In 2013, Butcher performed with
The Jesus and Mary Chain at
Primavera Sound, providing vocals on "
Just Like Honey". ==Artistry==