Once established as a rover, he consistently polled well in the Brownlow Medal vote count: • Polling 8 votes in 1946 (winner,
Don Cordner). • Finishing ninth to
Bert Deacon in 1947. • Finishing third to
Bill Morris in 1948. • Finishing eighth to
Ron Clegg, who won on a count-back from
Col Austen, in 1949. • Finishing sixth to
Allan Ruthven in 1950. • Finishing third to
Bernie Smith in 1951. • Finishing equal first with
Roy Wright in 1952. • Although their total votes and their "first votes" were equal, their "second votes" were not, and Wright (with more "second votes" and less "third votes" than Hutchison) was awarded the medal on a countback according to
the rules that applied at the time; however, those rules were changed in 1989, and Hutchison was retrospectively (and posthumously) awarded a Brownlow medal for the 1952 season. • Finishing first in 1953. • Polling 10 votes in 1954 (winner,
Roy Wright). • Finishing second, by one vote, to
Fred Goldsmith in 1955. • Polling 9 votes in 1956 (winner,
Peter Box). • Polling 5 votes in 1957 (winner,
Brian Gleeson). ==Death==