In December 1890, Earle had studied
hypnosis, reportedly to mesmerize a lady who had previously showed no interest in him. According to
Bill Stern in his book ''Bill Stern's Favorite Baseball Stories'', players recalled that Earle had a pair of piercing eyes, and gave anyone who he looked at a creepy, helpless feeling. He, Earle, and another teammate,
John Ake, were in a boat when a wave created by a passing-by
steamer capsized the boat. Barnes and Earle was able to swim to shore, but Ake drowned when he attempted to swim ashore himself. Barnes relates that he would never forget the look in Earles' eyes when he was watching Ake. Earle was good enough as a player, that no matter much he travelled around, he was able to catch on with some team.
Superstition more than anything else, finally kept Earle from continuing his professional playing career. ==Post-career==