Bimelech was undefeated as a two-year-old, winning his first over maidens at
Suffolk Downs by three lengths. In his next race, an allowance at Empire City, he wired the field. Bimelech's first
stakes race was at
Saratoga Race Course, where he defeated Briar Sharp and Andy K. in the
Saratoga Special Stakes. He then went on to win the
Hopeful Stakes by a neck. He ended his first season with a length and a half victory in the
Belmont Futurity Stakes and a four length win in the
Pimlico Futurity. Bimelech was named
American Champion Two-Year-Old Colt. He was also the Experimental Free Handicap Highweight at 130 pounds, a prodigious weight for a young horse. He became the favorite to win the 1940
Kentucky Derby; his winterbook odds of three to one were the lowest odds ever quoted for a Derby favorite up to that time. In his first race as a three-year-old, Bimelech took the
Blue Grass Stakes by two and a half lengths. He then won the
Derby Trial Stakes, beating a colt from
Milky Way Farm Stable called
Gallahadion. Still undefeated, Bimelech was the overwhelming choice for the Derby, which had had its purse raised to $75,000 added. It was his third start in 8 days. At six to one,
Charles S. Howard's
Mioland was the bettor's second choice. (Howard owned and raced the famous
Seabiscuit.) Gallahadion was thirty-five to one. In the Derby, Bimelech drifted farther and farther out from the rail and ran wide the entire race. The longer distance left him exhausted in the last few
furlongs. Gallahadion passed him in the final furlong. Bimelech's jockey,
Fred Smith, took the blame for the loss. A short time later, Bimelech beat Gallahadion in the
Preakness. He ran second in the
Withers Stakes, but records indicate this was due to poor preparation. So after the Withers, Bimelech went into heavy training and won the
Belmont Stakes. He struggled to win his next race, and it was discovered he was racing with an injured foot, which ended his racing that year. He took that year's honor of
American Champion Three-Year-Old Male Horse. When the new starting gates were introduced, Bimelech acted very badly while being loaded into the gate. After two races, Bradley retired his horse, fearing Bimelech would hurt himself. ==Stud record==