Critical response The series received generally positive reviews. Briana Lawrence of
The Mary Sue called the series "delightfully bonkers" and predicted future episodes would expand its "wacky, sapphic vibe". She later described the series as a "fantastically
campy golf (love) story".
Yuricon founder Erica Friedman argued that the series is similar to
isekai like ''
I'm in Love with the Villainess'' and argued it flouts the rules of the sports anime genre. She also called it a "delightful romp" with openly
yuri themes and said it is close to becoming the "greatest Yuri sports anime of all time". Alex Henderson of
Anime Feminist, reviewing the first episode, criticized the series for its "questionable tropes" and tackling "touchy subjects with [fairly] wild abandon" but still argued it is entertaining and the most fun they "ever had watching golf". Vrai Kaiser of the same publication, reviewing the first four episodes, argued that the show's "extreme sports angle" wasn't as strong as it could be, and described the show as "flashy" and "weird" but said that the rivalry between Eve and Aoi gave the series "an unexpectedly solid core". Reviewers for
Anime News Network were more positive. They stated that they either loved the series, said it was cool with an "utterly ridiculous premise", were invested in seeing where the Aoi/Eve relationship went, described it as the best sports anime of the season, or otherwise praised the series. ANN reviewer Farris also noted the "
memeable" nature of the series, while reviewer Jairus Taylor, of the same site, said this series compensated for golf not being exciting to watch by being "as flashy and over the top as possible with their presentation," in contrast to
Oi! Tonbo season 1, which was said to "overly technical." ANN reviewer Richard Eisenbeis described the series as a "sapphic-charged golf anime" which turned golf "into an extreme sport with high-stakes mob gambling" while James Beckett said it made golf "absolutely batshit insane...and...incredibly gay" and Caitlin Moore said that the series mix of mafia and stunt shots were "approximately equivalent to KISS-theming and black lights." All three contrasted it to
Sorairo Utility, which they said was based more in "the real world" but is still "pretty darned charming...and...incredibly gay" and is a "straightforward anime about girls playing golf."
Influence and legacy In March 2024, reviewers Christopher Farris and Steve Jones, of
Anime News Network, discussed whether the premiere of anime such as
Sorairo Utility,
Rising Impact,
Oi! Tonbo, later in 2024, is the result of
Birdie Wing causing a "golf anime renaissance" while comparing the series to
Haikyu!!,
Robot × LaserBeam,
Chihayafuru, and
Nobuyuki Fukumoto's
Nikaido Hell Golf, and
PuraOre! Pride of Orange. The characters from
Birdie Wing later had a crossover mini-anime with those from
Sorairo Utility, which began in February 2025. Producer Masakazu Kubo of
Tonbo later compared
Tonbo to
Birdie Wing, saying that the former series has "name-brand golf gear is pulled from reality as often as possible."
Accolades At the Anime Trending Awards, ''Birdie Wing: Golf Girls' Story'' was nominated for both Sports Anime of the Year and Best in Original Screenplay (
Yōsuke Kuroda) in 2023 and 2024. The series was also nominated for Best Original Anime in two consecutive years at the
Crunchyroll Anime Awards. ==Notes==