The club was established at the Chequers Hotel on 28 January 1874. Initially playing in crimson and green, their first match was played two weeks later, losing 2–1 to
East of England Nonconformist Grammar School. Following
World War II, the league resumed in 1945, with Bishop's Stortford in the Eastern Division. However, after finishing bottom of the Premier Division in 1948–49, they were relegated to Division One. In 1951 the club were founder members of the
Delphian League, which they won in
1954–55. After the league was disbanded in 1963 they joined Division Two of the
Athenian League, winning Division One in
1965–66 and the Premier Division in
1969–70. In
2012–13 they reached the FA Cup first round for the twelfth time, losing 2–1 at home to
Hastings United. At the end of the season they were transferred back to the Conference South, The
2021–22 season saw the club finish as runners-up in the Premier Division, before losing 3– to
Cheshunt in the play-off final. They went on to win the Premier Division title in
2022–23, earning promotion to the
National League North. However, they finished bottom of the division the
following season and were relegated to the Premier Division Central of the Southern League. ==Ground==