Reviews of the album were positive.
NME called the 'A' side "by far the best work they've ever done",
Tim Lott of
Record Mirror said the album "belies my expectations of The Stranglers as a spent force" and
Melody Maker stated the album, while not as good as their debut, showed that the band could "enlarge their ideas and still come up with good tunes". Some retrospective critics view
Black and White in a lesser light to the band's previous albums.
AllMusic called it "arguably the weakest" of the Stranglers' first three albums, "yet it still has some absolutely stunning moments." Conversely,
David Quantick writing for
BBC Music said "The Stranglers turned everything round on their third album", stating that the album was both "essential" and "extraordinary" and "displayed clear influences on the work of
Gang of Four and
Joy Division.".
Record Collector's Tim Peacock said
Black and White "served notice that the Stranglers had already outstripped punk", calling it "stark, compelling and every inch as necessary as contemporaneous envelope-pushers including
PiL's
First Issue and
Wire's
Chairs Missing." ==Track listing==