Variety reviewed the film upon its release onto VHS, praising its twist ending.
Joe Bob Briggs rated the film stars, writing that it's "the story of what would happen if
Luke Skywalker got into a
Fatal Attraction affair with a voodoo witch and she started hanging dead bloody roosters over his bed and really freaking out his dates."
Alexandra Heller-Nicholas reviewed the movie for
Fangoria in 2022, noting "
Black Magic Woman is a masterclass in a seemingly fluffy, disposable genre film, the spoonful of sugar that helps the ideological medicine go down. Because at the heart of this film lies some extraordinary twists and turns that pivot on assumptions about ethnicity, gender and sexuality". ==References==