Nye was selected by the
Dallas Cowboys in the
fifth round (130th overall) of the
1968 NFL/AFL draft as a
defensive tackle. Nye played in 27 games during his first two seasons with the Cowboys (1968 and 1969), but did not start any games. Although Nye had played principally at defensive tackle his last two years at Stanford, in drafting him the Cowboys believed that he lacked the speed and quickness to play on defense. They instead believed he could become an offensive guard in the NFL. Cowboys' offensive line coach
Jack Myers said Nye's high intelligence, along with his great strength and balance were the qualities the team saw that led them to this conclusion; and in fact, those qualities later made Nye a successful guard for the Cowboys. Myers also found that the coaches never had to repeat themselves with Nye, he did not make mistakes, and he was highly consistent as a player. Wilbur was a 1966 Stanford graduate, and had been Nye’s college teammate. Going into the 1970 season, the Cowboys planned to move 1969 All-Pro
Ralph Neely from tackle to guard and move future Hall of Fame tackle
Rayfield Wright Coach
Tom Landry traded Wilbur to the
Washington Redskins in late August, before the season started, intending to start Wright and Liscio at tackle and Neely and Niland at guard. Early in the
1970 season, Neely was injured. Landry chose Nye to replace Neely as the Cowboys' starting right guard. Tackle Liscio was subsequently injured, and once Neely recovered he was used at tackle to replace Liscio, with Nye remaining as a starting guard. Nye started 12 games that season, and went on to start every Cowboys' game at right guard from 1971 through 1976, when he retired. and
center Dave Manders. Nye played next to Wright for the remainder of Nye's career. In 1971, Neely went to left tackle where he was a Cowboys starter until he retired in 1977; and Niland remained the team's starting left guard from 1971 to 1975. In 1970, the Cowboys led the NFL in total
rushing yardage. After winning the first
National Football Conference (NFC) championship after the 1970 season, the Cowboys reached
Super Bowl V on January 17, 1971, losing to the
Baltimore Colts, 16–13. Nye started at right guard in the Super Bowl. The Cowboys reached the
Super Bowl again the following season, this time defeating the Miami Dolphins, 24–3. In 1971, they had led the NFL in points scored and total yards. In Super Bowl VI, the Cowboys had 252 rushing yards against the Dolphins, often gained behind the "devastating sweeps" of Nye and Niland; bringing the two guards to national attention. The 1972 Cowboys went to the
NFC championship, losing to the
Washington, 26–3; again with Nye at starting right guard. In the 1973 season, the Cowboys once again reached the
NFC championship game, losing to the
Minnesota Vikings, 27–10. Once more Nye started at right guard. Nye was selected to play in the
1974 Pro Bowl. The following season (1974), the Cowboys missed the playoffs, but still led the NFL in total yards and rushing yards. They reached the Super Bowl again in the 1975 season, losing
Super Bowl X to the Pittsburgh Steelers, 21–17; Nye starting in his final Super Bowl appearance. In
1976, Nye's final season, he was named to the All-NFC team and the
Pro Bowl. The January 17, 1977 Pro Bowl game would be his last game in the NFL. Nye announced his retirement on July 23,
1977. He was replaced by
Tom Rafferty. == Legacy and honors ==