In a contemporary review for
The New York Times, critic
Bosley Crowther wrote: "What Twentieth Century-Fox has done to turn Mr. Runyon's obscure fiction into the stuff of a musical film is obviously not calculated to preserve the late writer's racy style. Just a trace of his brash exaggeration is detectable in the mild of night clubs and horse-rooms and flea-bags presented in this film. ... However, this amiable picture ... doesn't go too far astray in the field of musical romance—the field in which it is strewn—so the question is not whether it is Runyon but whether it is passable fun. On that point this cheerful department expresses a mild affirmative." Critic John L. Scott of the
Los Angeles Times wrote: "The picture combines melodrama, music and hillbilly comedy in its light but diverting plot. ... Most of 'Bloodhounds of Broadway' is told In easygoing fashion. While most of the principals look tough—they run a huge horsebetting ring—they all have sentimental streaks and are present chiefly for comedy purposes." ==References==