Blueprints for the Black Market garnered generally positive reception from
Music critics. At
CCM Magazine, Brian Quincy Newcomb graded the album a B−, stating how the release "rocks assuredly, benefiting from the dynamic production of Aaron Sprinkle". Johnny Loftus rated it two stars, writing how the album "lack[s] any definition" and this makes the release "an utterly pleasant bore." At
Christianity Today, Russ Breimeier rated it three stars, saying that the album "sounds absolutely terrific."
Tony Cummings of
Cross Rhythms rated it a perfect ten squares, calling this "something special" that will be "A must for every rock buff." At Jesus Freak Hideout, Matt Gray rated it four-and-a-half stars, proclaiming this to be a "glorious debut". Bert Gangl of The Phantom Tollbooth rated it four stars, noting that the band "succeeds magnificently [...] crafting a work of sweeping, melodic, emotional, hook-laden beauty." At
Melodic, Pär Winberg rated the album three stars, remarking that it is an "Impressive debut." == Track listing ==