Orders continued his academic and athletic careers at West Virginia University. His arrival was a welcome one and greeted with some fanfare as the Mountaineers had gone
4–6–1,
2–8, &
5–5 from 1949 to 1951. Orders, alongside a host of new West Virginia players, led the Mountaineers to a
7–2 season in 1951. That season included a 16
–0 victory over eighteenth ranked
Pitt in 1952, considered one of the greatest victories in team history. He was named 1953 West Virginia Athlete of the Year. Mountaineers head coach
Art Lewis would later describe Orders as "the best in-the-line blocker I've ever coached" and
Fred Digby, founder of the Sugar Bowl, stated,"I don't believe I have ever seen a better offensive center than Bob Orders of West Virginia." Orders was credited with being a driving force behind West Virginia's success, being referred to as "the rock" in reference to his place in both the offensive and defensive lines. In 1960,
The Pittsburgh Press released an all-time West Virginia team which place Orders as the center and later named him the best player in the university's history. In 1996 Orders was inducted into the WVU Sports Hall of Fame, and was named an inaugural member of WVU’s Mountaineer Legends Society in 2016. He is also a member of the West Virginia Sports Writers Hall of Fame. While at West Virginia, Orders was in
ROTC,
Beta Theta Pi fraternity, and was the vice president of his senior class. == Later life ==