Boston Beaneaters (1B), right:
Herman Long (SS), bottom:
Jimmy Collins (3B), and left: Bobby Lowe (2B) After the 1889 baseball season, the
Boston Beaneaters purchased Lowe from the Milwaukee Brewers for $700 in a deal that has been described as "one of baseball's biggest bargains." He made his
Major League Baseball debut with the Beaneaters on April 19, 1890, and remained with the Beaneaters for 12 years through 1901. During his years in Boston, Lowe developed a reputation both as a hitter and a fielder. Listed at 5 ft 10 in (1.78 m), 150 pounds (68 kg), he hit right-handed and was considered one of the best second basemen of the 19th century. He was one of only three (along with
Kid Nichols and
Herman Long) to play on all five of the Beaneaters teams that won pennants in the 1890s. In 1891, Lowe tied a then major league record with six hits (four singles, a double, and a home run) in six at-bats. Having played mostly in the outfield in 1891 and 1892, he replaced
Joe Quinn at second base in 1893 and was the Beaneaters' starting second baseman for eight straight years, from 1893 to 1900. After the game, fans "showered $160 worth of silver on the plate for Lowe." In 1894, he led the National League with 613 at-bats and was among the leaders in fielding and particularly in batting, with 319 total bases (2nd in the league), 17 home runs (2nd in the league), 345 putouts as a second baseman (2nd in the league), 212 hits (4th in the league), 402 assists as a second baseman (4th in the league), and 158 runs scored (5th in the league).
Chicago Cubs On December 16, 1901, Lowe was purchased by the
Chicago Orphans from the Beaneaters. In April 1902, manager
Frank Selee named him team captain. He played for the Orphans, renamed the Cubs later that season, for two years. He was the starting second baseman in 1902. Although his batting statistics declined that year (.248 batting average), his .956 fielding percentage, 328 putouts, and 412 assists each ranked second among
National League second basemen. Despite solid fielding in 1904, Lowe's offensive output continued to decline as his batting average dropped to .207, 66 points below his career average of .273. After the injury, Lowe missed the remainder of the 1906 season and appeared in only 17 games (with 37 at-bats) in 1907, his final year in the major leagues. In 1911, Fred Tenney wrote a series of articles for
The New York Times selecting the greatest player in baseball history at each position. Having picked Johnny Evers at second base, Tenney chose Lowe as the best utility player of all time. In 1932, syndicated sportswriter Whitney Martin wrote a column arguing that Lowe ranked with
Bobby Doerr,
Joe Gordon,
Nap Lajoie, and
Eddie Collins as the greatest second basemen of all time. Martin argued that Lowe's accomplishments were overlooked because he played "at a time when the ball had more turtle in it than rabbit." He catalogued a number of Lowe's accomplishments to support the argument: • Hit four home runs and a single in one game for 17 total bases. • Batted over .300 from 1893 to 1897 "with the dead ball." • Made six hits in six at-bats for 10 total bases in another game. • Scored six runs in one game on May 3, 1895. • Played 34 consecutive games without an error, accepting 165 chances. In the 2001 book
The New Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract, writer
Bill James ranked Lowe as the 56th greatest second baseman of all-time. ==Coaching career==