There is some controversy over the number of these canons. In the
Apostolic Constitutions, the Apostolic Canons are eighty-five (occasionally eighty-four, a variant in the Manuscripts that arises from the occasional counting of two canons as one). In the latter half of the 6th century,
Joannes Scholasticus,
Patriarch of Constantinople from 565 to 577, published a collection of synodal decrees in which he included these eighty-five canons, and this number was finally consecrated for the Greek Church by the Trullan or
Quinisext Council of 692, which also confined the current Greek tradition of their Apostolic origin. Nevertheless, from their first appearance in the West they aroused suspicion. Canon 46 for example, that rejected all heretical baptism, was notoriously opposed to Roman and Western practice. In the so-called
Decretum traditionally attributed to
Pope Gelasius (492-96) they are denounced as an
apocryphal book, i. e. not recognized by the Catholic Church, though this note of censure was probably not in the original
Decretum, but with others was added under
Pope Hormisdas (514-23). Consequently, in a second edition (lost, except preface) of
his Collectio canonum, prepared under the latter pope, Dionysius Exiguus omitted them; even in the first edition he admitted that very many in the West were loath to acknowledge them (
quamplurimi quidem assensum non prœbuere facilem).
Hincmar of Reims (died 882) declared that they were not written by the Apostles, and as late as the middle of the 11th century, Western theologians (
Cardinal Humbert, 1054) distinguished between the eighty-five Greek canons that they declared
apocryphal, and the fifty Latin canons recognized as
orthodox rules by antiquity. ==Influence==